• Cambios en el aspecto y funcionamiento del foro. Ver detalles

Pregunta Eaten Alive versions confusion and clarifications?

Maxym

HideOuter Senior
Analysing Discogs, I can guess stuff, but I'm not 100% sure, are there official Eaten Alive tracks that exist on vinyl and that don't exist in digital.

Here is what I see so far
Vinyl
Ref.Variation titlesDurationMixed bySome disc referencesDigital match?
V1Eaten alive (likely album) version3:50Humberto Gatica7", 45 RPM [PB-14181]D1
V2Extended Remix
Extended Re-mix
5:51Francois Kevorkian*, Ron St. GermainUS 12'' 45 RPM [1564696]=D4?
V3Edited Remix
Singe Version Edited Re-mix
3:48Francois Kevorkian*, Ron St. GermainUS 12'' 45 RPM [1564696]No match?
V4Instrumental
Instrumental Version
5:51Francois Kevorkian*, Ron St. GermainUS 12'' 45 RPM [1564696]D5 or "No match"?
V5Extended Remix5:44Francois Kevorkian*, Ron St. GermainEurope 12'' [K 062 20 0791 6]=D5?
=V2? (shortened)
V6(album version)3:50Humberto Gatica=V1?

Digital (note: not necessarilyfiles, CDs are digital)

Ref.Variation titlesDurationMixed bySome disc referencesVinyl match?
D1Eaten alive (album version)3:53
3:50
Humberto Gatica
Humberto Gatica
1989, Album, Repress [CDP 7 46184 2]
Album, 2014 extended remaster
V1
D2Single Mix3:51?Album, 2014 extended remaster?
D3Single Mix Instrumental3:58?Album, 2014 extended remaster?
D4Hot Extended Dance Mix5:54?Album, 2014 extended remaster=D6=V2?
D5Hot Extended Dance Mix Instrumental5:51?Album, 2014 extended remasterV4 or "No match"?
D6Extended Re-Mix5:52Francois Kevorkian*, Ron St. Germain1989, Album, Repress [CDP 7 46184 2]=D4=V2?

Kind of things I wonder: Is "D2 - Single Mix" the same as "album mix"? Is it the Kevorkian/St. Germain mix? Is Hot Extended Dance Remix actually the Kevorkian/St. Germain mix or is it yet another mix? Are V4 and D5 the same thing? If they are, there should be not match for V3? (Since D2 is not supposed to be the same mix as D4...) If there aren't, then that V4 5:51 instrumental doesn't exist in digital?
And weirdly I come to wonder is "Single Mix" and "Hot Extended Dance Mix" are all versions of the the same mix...but then why would they have different titles on the same release?

Thank you for info! Help me sleep easier!
 

Maxym

HideOuter Senior
I finally took some time to do some comparison. Mostly comparing waveforms to spot differences and similarities.

Instrumental version from 12'' is "Hot Extended Dance Mix Instrumental" from 2014 CD.
Extended Re-mix from 12'' is "Extended Re-Mix" from 1989 CD and "Hot Extended Dance Mix" from 2014 CD.
The "Single Mix" from 2014 CD has very similar structure to album version with more instrumental (like a guitar, then I'm not always good to spot instruments differences)
For some reason, the "Single Mix Instrumental" has a slightly ending, which explains why it a it slightly longer.

My conclusion right now is that the 2014 double CD (probably) has all versions.
Though, I think the sound of the 12'' slightly superior (at least on the one that I have).

I don't feel like update the table here above.
 
Última edición:
Arriba